Nuvitru Logo

Healthy Peanut Butter Cups {Pumpkin Style}

healthy peanut butter cups

Healthy Peanut Butter Cups {Pumpkin Style}

Do I need to really explain the love for peanut butter cups? I didn’t think so. These healthy peanut butter cups are perfect if you’re wanting a treat to make either for Halloween or any average day. They are INSANELY easy + you’ll think to yourself – “how did I ever NOT make these?” Having good molds makes this recipe easy + since we’re talking {pumpkin style}, here is where you can get your own pumpkin silicon molds.

Feel free to use in this recipe almond butter or another butter, instead of peanut butter. For me though, I really wanted to use some peanut butter – that classic feel, ya feel me? Another favorite nut butter is cashew butter, so if you can’t do almonds OR peanuts, that is a great option!

If you love this recipe, try our healthier homemade snickers. You won’t buy the regular stuff any more!! I keep our Snickers in the freezer, so we can have them for a longer period of time + enjoy them when we want!

When you make these healthy peanut butter cups, tag us over on Instagram + Facebook @nuvitruwellness, so we can see your beautiful creation! We love connecting with our tribe over there, so make sure you are there and join the conversation!! Also check out these delicious Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookies as another yummy snack!

Healthy Peanut Butter Cups {Pumpkin Style}

Pumpkin Peanut Butter Cups

Servings: 20 Pumpkins


  • 1.5 Cups Chocolate Chips Enjoy-Life
  • 2 Tbs Coconut Oil
  • Peanut Butter Organic
  • Pumpkin Silicon Molds We bought ours at Target


  • On medium heat on the stove, heat up a small pot of a couple inches of water.
  • Put the chocolate chips and coconut oil into a glass jar.
  • Put the glass jar into the pot of water (this acts like a double broiler and helps you avoid microwave use) + use a spoon to stir the chocolate chips + coconut oil until everything is melted.
  • Once melted, take off heat.
  • Spray pumpkin silicon molds with coconut oil.
  • In each mold, put enough chocolate to cover the bottom.
  • Put in freezer for 5 minutes.
  • Take out of freezer and put a teaspoon of peanut butter on top of each chocolate pumpkin. Freeze again for 5 minutes.
  • Take out of freezer and top with the rest of the melted chocolate. Freeze for another five minutes.
  • Take out of molds + store in fridge! Enjoy!
Avatar for Lahana Vigliano
Lahana Vigliano

Lahana Vigliano is a Certified Clinical Nutritionist and CEO of Nuvitru Wellness. She has her Bachelor's Degree in Nutrition Science and Masters Degree in Nutrition Science and Functional Medicine. She is currently pursuing her doctorate degree in Clinical Nutrition. Lahana and her team help support women who struggle with weight loss, hormonal imbalances, digestive issues, chronic fatigue, and many other lingering issues that leaves women not feeling their best. She uses food as medicine, as well as herbs and supplements when needed, to support her clients. She looks at the whole body holistically making sure women are understanding how nutrition, sleep, stress, and their environment impact their health. Connect with her on Facebook + Instagram (@nuvitruwellness).